DISQUS

djchuang.com: many kinds of emerging church

  • stephen shields · 1 year ago
    great post, dj
  • solomon li · 1 year ago
    controversial issue dj. interesting to boot.

    i have not read the so-called emerging or emergent church writings, but it seems that there are some extremes going on there to try to get away from what is perceived as a failed evangelical mega-church seeker sensitive model to a degree... along with other interesting things.

    so far as i know they're in line with a lot of old school pietism (as in the movement). it's difficult and mirky to trace... and furthermore, what do they mean by their terms? often, it seems like they're so ambiguous on what they believe... like in the term "missional". what is that? i know there have been many an article which pre-supposes the wrong thing, and yet they don't give us anything concrete.

    fascinating subject though. there are a few things right that i see there... but then again, there's a lot of questionable things like the abandonment of the authority of the church. without structure under whose authority are you? how can you be held accountable for things like church discipline?

    then again, they're right in saying that it's not about bringing people "into" church, but rather it's a challenge for Christians to not settle into complacency and go out there to engage people... to obey the mission of God to preach the gospel...

    oi... what a headache...

    thanks for the post dj!!!
  • andrew jones · 1 year ago
    dj- this is a great resource

    maybe i should email you my 5 models of emerging (postmodern) church that I wrote in 1999 and was published by GenNext? let me know.
  • andrew jones · 1 year ago
  • djchuang · 1 year ago
    Andrew, thanks for posting your article on 5 models of emerging church, circa 1999! Great read, and a bit entertaining at that :)

    Solomon, perhaps this is part of the milieu of the 21st century, that words are losing their concrete meaning, and people can (largely) define the meaning of the words they use. Thus, it seems ambiguous to try to understand exactly what some emerging churches believe or doesn't believe. Some people say that "certainty is over-rated." And, I think, it's being called an emerging church because it is still in process of emerging, and it is not yet an emerged church that knows its contructs, structures, and definitions.
  • andrew jones · 1 year ago
    you are very welcome.
  • Joel · 1 year ago
    I'm still reading about what the Puritan's have to say about ecclesiology but thanks anyway.
  • MichaelG · 7 months ago
    Hey, I use a similar service to Earth Class when I travel, http://www.privatebox.co.nz They seem to do a very good job!